Are Chain Collars Good for Dogs?

Chain collars can stop pulling in some cases, but they come with more risks than most dog parents realize. While some trainers still use choke chains as a correction tool, modern alternatives like martingales and harnesses are often safer, smarter choices for everyday walks and training. 

What Is a Chain Collar, and Why Do Some People Use Them?

Chain collars, often called choke chains, tighten around your dog’s neck when they pull and loosen when they stop. These collars were originally designed for obedience training, especially in the mid-20th century when dog training focused more on correction than communication.

Some trainers still use them today, particularly for large or reactive breeds, arguing they offer quick control in high-pressure situations. But here’s the catch: they only work if used correctly.

Should Dogs Wear Chain Collars at All?

• If they make a distinct sound that some dogs respond to as a cue, not just pressure
• If they may help prevent escape in breeds prone to slipping out of regular collars

Mistakes to Avoid

• Using them for everyday walking
• Leaving them on unattended
• Ignoring proper fit

When (and How) Chain Collars Might Be Used Safely

Here’s when they might be appropriate:

• You’re working with a trainer who knows how to use pressure-release tools correctly.
• Your dog is physically suited to handle one, meaning no breathing issues, neck fragility, or high anxiety.
• You use a safer version, like a limited-slip martingale, that prevents over-tightening and loosens quickly when pressure stops.

Are There Better Options To Stop a Dog From Pulling?

Helpful Resource -> Types Of Dog Collars

If your dog walks like they’re chasing a squirrel on a mission, the right gear makes all the difference. Here’s what works (and why):

• Harnesses: Distribute pulling pressure across the chest instead of the neck. Good for puppies and small breeds.
• Martingale Collars: Tighten just enough to prevent escape, but won’t choke.
• Head Collars: Guide your dog’s direction by the nose, not the neck.

Explore our Fi Compatible Reflective Chain Martingale Dog Collar – Optional Name Plate.

How to Choose Based on Your Dog

1. Size & Breed: Narrow heads? Try a martingale. Brachycephalic dogs? Stick to harnesses.
2. Pulling Behavior: Mild puller? Try a harness or martingale. 
3. Sensitivity: Dogs with anxiety or skin issues may need softer fabrics
4. Training Goals: Are you teaching loose-leash walking or just preventing escapes? Your goal should guide your gear.

Is It Better to Train a Dog With a Collar or Harness?

This is one of the most common questions we hear, and the answer depends on your dog’s needs and your training goals.

Pros of Collars:

• Familiar and convenient. Most dogs are used to wearing collars, and they’re quick to put on for everyday use.
• Visible ID. A collar makes it easy to display your dog’s name and your contact info.
• Ideal for calm dogs. If your pup already walks politely on leash, a well-fitted collar is often all you need.

Pros of Harnesses:

• Gentler on the neck. Harnesses shift tension away from the throat, especially useful for small breeds or those prone to tracheal collapse.
• Improved control. A front-clip harness helps redirect pulling dogs, making leash training smoother.
• Avoids pressure hotspots. No digging into the neck or damaging the coat.

If your dog pulls hard, is still learning, or has a delicate build, we recommend starting with a harness or martingale combo. And remember: your gear should support your training, not replace it.

Helpful Resource -> Collars Vs Harnesses

What’s the Paw-fect Choice for Your Dog?

What works for a 90-lb German Shepherd could be way too intense for a 10-lb Cavapoo. And what keeps a reactive dog safe might overwhelm a puppy still learning the ropes.

When in doubt, go gentle. Reach out to a pro. And remember: you don’t have to compromise on style to prioritize safety.

Ready to Ditch the Guesswork? Try Mimi Green’s Safer, Smarter Collar Options

If you’re here, you’re probably wondering how to keep your dog safe, stylish, and under control, without using tools that could harm them.

That’s exactly what we do at Mimi Green.

We offer handcrafted, made-to-order solutions like:

• Chain Martingale Collars – With limited slip functionality and engraved nameplates, they’re great for dogs who back out of regular collars but don’t need harsh correction.
• Waterproof Martingales – Soft, stylish, and suited for everything from daily walks to muddy adventures.
• Custom-Fit Harnesses and Accessories – Built for comfort, control, and coordination.

👉 Explore Our Collars: Made to order. Made with love. Made for your one-of-a-kind pup.