Blog

Best Dog Collar for Border Collie

Posted on by Carlton Clark
21
Jul

Martingale collars are best for Border Collies, they prevent escapes and offer gentle control for walks and training. For working dogs that herd or roam, a wide flat buckle collar or Fi-compatible option is safer to avoid snags. Fit, durability, and comfort matter most.

I would also acknowledge that border collies are bred to herd (usually sheep) so if they are a working dog, flat collar or Fi collar is my rec.

TL;DR Best collars for Border Collies

Border Collies are famously smart, and famously squirmy. With narrow heads and boundless energy, they’ve earned a reputation as collar escape artists. 

Whether they’re herding kids in the backyard or sprinting after squirrels, their collar needs to stay put, feel comfortable, and never hold them back.

That’s why the right collar is choosing a fit that won’t slip, materials that won’t rub, and features that support training and safety for a high-drive breed.

At Mimi Green, we make custom, made-to-order dog collars designed for real-life Border Collies. Our Martingale collars gently tighten to prevent slip-outs, our Biothane collars shrug off mud and water, and every style can be personalized just for your pup, with embroidery, engraved buckles, or GPS-compatible attachments.

If you’re looking for the best collar to match your Border Collie’s personality, drive, and daily routine, we’ll walk you through every option.

Want to know why martingales beat flat collars, what size most Border Collies need, and how to avoid fur matting? Keep reading, we’ve got it all below.

What Size Collar Should I Get for a Border Collie?

Most Border Collies need a 14–18″ collar, but measurement is key.

Border Collies fall into that tricky mid-size range—not too big, but agile enough to wiggle out of loose collars. Getting the right size isn’t just about comfort, it’s about safety.

How to Get the Right Fit:

  • Wrap a soft tape measure around the base of your dog’s neck (just above the shoulders).
  • Leave room for two fingers between the collar and neck—this prevents chafing and slipping.
  • For martingales, measure both the widest part of the head and neck, then size up 1.5–2 inches from the neck measurement.
  • For Border Collies, Mimi Green recommends:

Pro Tip: Puppies grow fast! Choose an adjustable collar or plan to size up as they grow.

Collar vs. Harness: Which is Better for a Border Collie?

Collars are best for ID and training, harnesses for pulling and control.

The right setup depends on your dog’s behavior, and your walking routine.

Use a Collar If:

  • Your Border Collie walks calmly on leash
  • You’re focusing on ID tags and casual wear
  • You’re training with a martingale or flat collar

Use a Harness If:

  • Your dog pulls or has a sensitive neck
  • You go on hikes, runs, or long walks
  • You need more control during leash training

Mimi Green Harness Options:

Training Collars for Border Collies: What Works?

Featured Product: Waterproof Biothane Martingale – Quick Release with Optional Engraving

Martingales are safe for everyday training; avoid harsh tools.

Border Collies are whip-smart but strong-willed. They respond best to training methods that are consistent and gentle.

We suggest Martingale Collars for Border Collies. They  encourage loose-leash walking without harsh correction and are also great for young or energetic Border Collies.

Start training with positive reinforcement first. Treats, praise, and a well-fitted collar are more effective (and safer) than punishment.

Materials That Matter: Comfort, Durability & Style

Featured Product: Martingale Engraved Buckle Dog Collar *14 Velvet Dog Collar Colors

Biothane, velvet, and leather are ideal, skip stiff or scratchy options.

A Border Collie’s collar sees a lot: dirt, rain, fur friction, and constant movement. Choosing the right material makes all the difference in comfort and long-term wear.

Top Material Picks:

  • Biothane
    • Waterproof, odor-proof, quick-drying
    • Great for dogs in wet or muddy regions
    • Safe to chew-resistant under supervision
  • Velvet
    • Super soft on long-haired dogs
    • Prevents fur matting and neck irritation
    • Easy to wash and quick to dry
  • Leather
    • Durable, classic, and ages beautifully
    • Better for dry climates or non-swimmers
  • Nylon
    • Lightweight and breathable
    • Ideal for low-bulk everyday use 

Features to Look For in a Border Collie Collar

Safety and comfort start with these collar must-haves.

Not all collars are built with smart, fast-moving dogs in mind. These key features keep your Border Collie secure, stylish, and irritation-free.

Must-Have Features:

  • Adjustability – Allows room for growth and seasonal coat changes
  • Breakaway or Quick-Release Buckles – Prevents accidents if the collar snags
  • Slide-On or Engraved Tags – No jingling or risk of snagging during zoomies
  • Reflective Stitching or Bold Colors – Boosts visibility during off-leash hikes
  • Fi-Compatible Options – Real-time GPS tracking and activity monitoring

Style Tip: Mimi Green collars can be customized with engraved nameplates, embroidered names, and bold color combos that match your dog’s personality.

How to Measure Your Border Collie’s Neck for a Perfect Fit

Neck size plus 2 fingers equals the paw-fect fit.

A good-looking collar won’t do much if it’s not fitted correctly. Follow these steps to ensure a snug, comfortable, and safe fit.

Step-by-Step Measuring Guide:

  1. Use a soft measuring tape
  2. Measure the base of your dog’s neck (right above the shoulders)
  3. Slide two fingers between the tape and your dog’s neck
  4. For martingale collars, also measure the widest part of the head

When to Replace Your Dog’s Collar

Monthly checks help avoid fraying, rust, or irritation.

Even the best collar needs retirement eventually. A worn collar can slip, chafe, or fail when it matters most.

General Replacement Guidelines:

  • Replace every 6–12 months for active dogs
  • Wash soft collars monthly (machine or hand-wash depending on fabric)
  • Rotate between two collars to extend their life

10 FAQs About Border Collie Collars

Real answers to real questions from dog parents like you.

  1. What size collar fits a Border Collie? Most adult Border Collies need a 14–18″ collar. Mimi Green recommends Medium or Medium-Long sizing.
    2. Should Border Collies wear collars or harnesses? Collars are best for daily ID and leash training. Harnesses work better for pullers or sensitive necks.
    3. What age is hardest to manage in Border Collies? 6 to 18 months, high energy, low impulse control. Choose adjustable collars during this growth phase.
    4. What do Border Collies love most in a walk setup? Freedom to move, lightweight gear, and breathable materials. Many prefer collars that don’t jingle or rub their necks.
    5. Are martingales safe for Border Collies? Yes, when fitted correctly, they offer control without choking.
    6. Do collars cause hair matting? Only if they’re too tight or made from rough material. Velvet and Biothane help prevent matting and chafing.
    7. Can a collar stop my dog from slipping out? A properly fitted martingale is designed to do just that.
    8. What’s the best color for a red/blue merle?Jewel tones, neutrals, and earth tones look great on merles.
    9. Is Biothane safe if chewed? It’s highly durable, but no collar is chew-proof, fit is key to prevent chewing.
    10. Should I leave the collar on at home? It depends, remove for naps or crate time if your pup tends to snag it.

Final Checklist: Border Collie Gear Must-Haves

Everything your smart, stylish pup needs for safe, comfy adventures.

  • Custom martingale or flat collar (based on behavior)
  • Soft, breathable fabric like velvet, Biothane, or leather
  • Matching leash with grip-friendly handle
  • Engraved buckle or jingle-free tag
  • Adjustable harness for pullers or hikes
  • Reflective stitching for visibility
  • Fi-compatible collar for tracking and peace of mind

The Best Fit for Your Border Collie Starts Here

Your Border Collie isn’t a one-size-fits-all kind of dog. They’re fast, smart, and full of personality, and they deserve gear that reflects that.

At Mimi Green, every collar is made to order in the USA, crafted by hand using durable materials like velvet, Biothane, and leather. 

Whether you need a martingale that won’t slip, a waterproof collar for mountain trails, or a stylish flat collar that feels like home, we’ve got you covered.

Popular solutions for Border Collies include:

  • Custom Velvet Martingale Collars – Gentle, secure, and perfect for sensitive pups
  • Waterproof Biothane Collars – Built for dirt, water, and everything in between
  • Engraved Buckle Collars – Lightweight, jingle-free, and personalized just for your dog

Ready to find the collar that keeps up with your Collie? 👉 Explore our collar and find the perfect fit for your Border Collie now

Carlton Clark