Blog

Dog Collar Buckle vs Clip/Quick-Release

Posted on by Carlton Clark
16
Jun

Belt-style buckles offer max security for strong pullers, while quick-release buckles (also called clips) are perfect for speed and convenience. Choose a buckle for durability and security; opt for clips for ease and daycare safety. The best collar depends on your dog’s size, habits, and environment.

Not all dog collars are created equal, and the difference often comes down to something as small as the buckle. In this guide, we’re walking you through the pros, cons, and surprising truths behind buckles vs. clips, so you can find the collar that’s just right for your pup. 

Let’s dig in.

What’s the Difference Between a Belt Buckle and a Quick-Release Buckle?

Before diving into safety, comfort, or style, let’s start with how belt buckle and clip/quick-release collars actually work. While they both serve the same purpose, keeping your pup safely collared, the mechanics and use-cases differ in key ways.

At Mimi Green, we refer to “buckle collars” as belt buckles and “clip collars” as quick-release buckles.

Belt Buckle Collars (Metal or Plastic)

Belt Buckle Collars function like a traditional belt. You thread the strap through a metal or plastic buckle and secure it using pre-punched holes.

We have personalized options like the Fi Compatible Waterproof Engraved Reflective Dog Collar from the photo.

Why choose it?

These collars are the go-to for durability. The belt buckle stays locked even when your dog is pulling hard, making them perfect for strong or high-energy pups and they’re also less prone to accidental release.

However, those collars can be a bit trickier to fasten and remove quickly, which matters more in certain high-pressure situations (we’ll get to that next).

Clip Collars (Quick-Release or Side-Release)

Clip/Quick-Release collars, on the other paw, snap shut with a side-release mechanism. Just pinch the tabs and the collar pops open. Easy in, easy out. Check our fabric designer collars like the ‘Maizie’ Floral Flannel Personalized Martingale Dog Collar from the photo.

Why choose it?

Clip/Quick-release collars are popular for their convenience, especially in households with multiple dogs or wriggly pups who hate standing still. They’re a practical pick for everyday wear in controlled environments.

Which One is Safer for Dogs Who Pull or Lunge?

Safety is about staying secure when your dog makes sudden moves. Whether your pup is a casual stroller or a full-body puller, how the closure handles pressure makes all the difference.

Why Metal Hardware Wins for Strong Pullers

Metal hardware doesn’t give under pressure. Whether it’s a traditional belt-style buckle or a metal quick-release clip, the added strength can make a real difference when your dog lunges, pulls, or takes off without warning.

When Clip (Quick-Release Buckles) COULD Become Risky

It might seem like plastic clips are the weaker option, but at Mimi Green, that’s not the case. Our quick-release plastic buckles are made from military-grade materials that are built to last through daily wear, wild adventures, and all kinds of weather. They’re lightweight, durable, and a favorite for wiggly pups who need something strong and easy to use.

What matters most? Choosing the buckle style that suits your pup’s needs, and trusting that every Mimi Green collar is designed with safety and quality in mind, no matter the material.

So, what’s the takeaway? Don’t judge a buckle by its material alone: what really matters is how it’s built.

Can I Just Swap the Buckle Type?

Yes, many pet parents choose to upgrade their plastic clip to a metal clip for added style. It’s a smart move, especially when the collar is otherwise comfortable and well-made.

But here’s the thing: a strong closure only works if the rest of the collar is up to par. That’s why every Mimi Green collar is designed as a complete system, from fabric to hardware, so your pup gets security, comfort, and style in one handcrafted piece.

Comfort & Convenience: Which Is Best for Daily Use?

Even the strongest collar won’t get used if it’s a pain to put on. Daily practicality plays a big role in choosing your closure style, especially if you’re dressing a squirmy pup, arthritic senior, or multi-dog household.

  • Clip collars are easy on, easy off
  • Buckles offer a more secure fit
  • Does weight matter? Yes! While strength is a win for buckles, weight can be a downside, especially for small breeds. A heavy metal buckle might feel clunky on a Chihuahua or Pomeranian.

What About Breakaway Collars and Special Cases?

Some dogs, and households, call for something a little different than your standard collar. Whether it’s for indoor safety, specialized work, or style preferences, these alternatives can offer unique benefits when used appropriately.

Breakaway options like the Nylon Collar from the photo are designed to open automatically under pressure. That’s great if your dog’s collar snags on a crate wire or furniture leg indoors, but dangerous if used on a walk.

These are most commonly used for cats, but some dog parents like them for unsupervised, at-home wear. If you’re considering one for your dog, look for styles with a leash-safe D-ring bypass. Otherwise, never attach a leash to a true breakaway collar.

Style, Personalization & Collar Culture

Your dog’s collar doesn’t have to be boring, and honestly, it shouldn’t be. Function matters, but style and identity matter too. Check some of our options:

Buckle or Clip, Which Is Right for You?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, and that’s the point. Your choice depends on your dog’s size, personality, and lifestyle. Here’s a quick breakdown:

Dog Type / Need Recommended Closure Why
Strong pullers/leash tuggers Belt-Style Buckle (Metal) Maximum security and durability
Puppies / senior dogs Quick-Release Buckle (Plastic) Lightweight, easy to handle
Daycare regulars Quick-Release Buckle Emergency-friendly during play
Tiny dogs or fashion pups Quick-Release or Mini Buckle Lightweight and stylish

We believe in the right collar, for your dog’s build, behavior, and the life you live together.

Ready to Find the Right Collar for Your Pup?

At Mimi Green we offer a curated range of premium materials, Pair that with countless color combinations, stylish prints, and customizable hardware options, and you can design a collar that’s truly one-of-a-kind.

  • Choose from a full palette of colors and patterns, from earthy to neon.
  • Pick the closure type that fits your dog’s lifestyle: belt, quick-release, or both.
  • Customize your collar with engraving, embroidery, or upgraded metal hardware.

Each collar is handcrafted in the USA by a team that believes your dog deserves one made just for them.

👉 Find Your Dog’s Perfect Collar Now

Carlton Clark